Concrete Resurfacing vs. Replacement: What’s Best for Your Property?

Your driveway, patio, or walkway is more than just a surface — it’s the foundation of your property’s first impression. Over time, even the toughest concrete starts to show signs of wear: cracks, discoloration, surface pits, or uneven areas.

If you’ve noticed these issues, you’re probably asking the same question many Davis homeowners face: Should I resurface my concrete, or replace it entirely?

Both options can transform your space, but they differ in cost, longevity, and the type of damage they address. In this guide, we’ll break down concrete resurfacing vs. replacement to help you make an informed, cost-effective decision for your property in Davis, CA or anywhere in Yolo County.

Understanding the Basics

What Is Concrete Resurfacing?

Concrete resurfacing is a process that gives old or worn concrete a fresh, new surface without removing the entire slab. A thin overlay — typically a mix of cement, polymers, and bonding agents — is applied over the existing concrete to restore appearance and functionality.

This method can fix minor surface damage, cover cosmetic imperfections, and even add decorative finishes like stamped or colored concrete.

Resurfacing is ideal for:

• Surface cracks, scaling, or discoloration

• Driveways or patios that are structurally sound

• Property owners wanting a fast, affordable upgrade

The result is a smooth, durable surface that looks brand new without the cost and disruption of full replacement.

What Is Concrete Replacement?

Concrete replacement involves demolishing and removing the existing slab, preparing the base, and pouring entirely new concrete.

It’s the right choice when the structural integrity of the old slab is compromised — for example, if the concrete is severely cracked, uneven, or sinking due to soil movement or poor installation.

Replacement is ideal for:

• Deep or spreading cracks

• Foundation or drainage issues

• Structural damage caused by tree roots or erosion

• Old concrete that’s beyond repair

Though it’s a more extensive process, replacement ensures long-term stability and eliminates hidden issues under the surface.

Comparing Resurfacing and Replacement

When deciding between resurfacing and replacement, consider the following key factors.

1. Condition of Your Existing Concrete

Before making a decision, a professional inspection is essential.

• If your concrete is mostly intact (no deep cracks or shifting), resurfacing is likely enough.

• If your concrete has structural damage or movement beneath the surface, replacement is the better investment.

At Davis Concrete Services, we always perform a thorough site assessment to determine whether your slab can be resurfaced safely or if it’s too compromised for an overlay.

2. Cost Comparison

Budget often plays a major role in your decision.

Option:

• Resurfacing - $4 – $10 per sq. ft. Average Cost (Davis, CA area)

Best For: Surface-level damage, appearance upgrades

• Replacement: $8 – $18 per sq. ft. Average Cost (Davis, CA area)

Best For: Severe damage or structural issues

Resurfacing typically costs 50–60% less than replacement. It’s a great way to refresh your driveway or patio without a major construction project.

However, if your slab is beyond repair, replacement avoids spending money on a temporary fix.

3. Durability & Longevity

• Resurfaced concrete lasts 10–15 years with proper care.

• Replaced concrete can last 30 years or more if poured and sealed correctly.

In Davis, where weather conditions are generally mild but prone to temperature swings and occasional heavy rain, both options perform well — provided they’re professionally installed and sealed to resist moisture.

4. Aesthetic Options

One of the biggest advantages of resurfacing is the customization potential.

You can choose:

• Stamped overlays that mimic stone, brick, or tile

• Colored finishes to complement your home’s exterior

• Slip-resistant textures for safety

Replacement can also be decorative — you can pour new stamped or stained concrete — but resurfacing offers the same design possibilities at a lower cost if the base is in good shape.

5. Time & Disruption

Resurfacing is fast — often completed in 1 to 3 days, depending on the size and prep required.

Replacement is more extensive, typically taking 5 to 10 days including demolition, site preparation, pouring, curing, and finishing.

If you’re looking for minimal disruption, resurfacing is clearly the quicker route. But if your concrete is severely damaged, replacement ensures the issue is resolved for decades to come.

6. Environmental Impact

In environmentally conscious communities like Davis, CA, sustainability matters.

Resurfacing wins here — it reuses your existing slab, reducing demolition waste and the need for new materials. Replacement involves hauling away old concrete, which increases waste and energy use.

If your goal is a greener, lower-impact project, resurfacing is the eco-friendly choice — assuming your base concrete is still stable.

Pros and Cons Overview

Here’s a quick reference to help you decide:

Option: Concrete Resurfacing

Pros - Lower cost - Quick installation - Eco-friendly - Custom finishes

Cons - Not suitable for major cracks or structural issues - Shorter lifespan than replacement

Option: Concrete Replacement

Pros - Long-lasting - Solves deep structural problems - Complete design freedom

Cons - Higher cost - More time and labor - More waste generation

Common Scenarios in Davis, CA

Scenario 1: Mild Surface Cracks on a Driveway

If your driveway has hairline cracks or surface stains, resurfacing is a smart choice.
It renews the look and extends the life of the slab without the expense of full replacement.

Scenario 2: Uneven Patio with Poor Drainage

If water pools after rain or your patio is uneven, replacement may be the only safe solution.
This allows for proper grading and drainage installation, preventing future issues.

Scenario 3: Decorative Upgrade for Curb Appeal

If you simply want a modern, stylish finish, resurfacing with stamped or colored overlays can dramatically improve your property’s appearance and resale value — especially appealing in Davis’s competitive real estate market.

How to Know When Replacement Is Absolutely Necessary

Some signs can’t be ignored. If you see these, full replacement is your best bet:

• Deep cracks wider than ¼ inch that spread across the slab

• Uneven lifting or sinking (slab movement)

• Crumbled or soft spots in multiple areas

• Poor drainage or soil erosion under the surface

• Old, patchwork repairs that no longer hold up

In these cases, resurfacing would only mask deeper issues temporarily. Replacement ensures structural stability and eliminates future maintenance headaches.

Maintenance After Each Option

Whether you resurface or replace, maintenance is key to long-term performance.

After Resurfacing:

• Keep off the surface for 24–48 hours (depending on product).

• Clean regularly to prevent grime buildup.

• Reseal every 2–3 years to protect the finish and color.

After Replacement:

• Allow curing for at least 7 days before heavy use.

• Seal after 28 days for maximum protection.

• Avoid deicing salts and use gentle cleaning products.

Proper care ensures your concrete — new or renewed — remains attractive and durable for years.

Why Professional Installation Matters

DIY kits for resurfacing may look tempting, but proper surface prep, bonding, and finishing are crucial for long-term success.

At Davis Concrete Services, our experienced team ensures:

• The existing surface is properly cleaned and etched.

• Cracks are repaired before applying overlays.

• The mix and bonding agents are chosen for Davis’s climate.

• Decorative finishes are applied evenly and sealed correctly.

For replacement projects, we handle everything from demolition to site grading, ensuring a stable, level base for your new concrete.

Professional workmanship not only ensures quality results — it also protects your investment.

Making the Right Choice for Your Property

Here’s a quick decision guide:

• Choose resurfacing if:

  • Damage is cosmetic or superficial.

  • You want a decorative upgrade.

  • Your budget or timeline is limited.

  • The slab is structurally sound.

• Choose replacement if:

  • Cracks, sinking, or shifting are visible.

  • There are drainage or foundation issues.

  • The concrete is over 25 years old.

  • You want a completely new layout or design.

If you’re unsure, schedule an inspection. We’ll help you evaluate your concrete’s condition and recommend the most cost-effective, long-lasting solution.

The Bottom Line

For many homeowners in Davis, CA, concrete resurfacing provides a beautiful, durable upgrade at a fraction of the cost of replacement. But if your existing slab is structurally compromised, replacement is the smarter, longer-term investment.

Whichever path you choose, the key is expert installation and proper maintenance — both of which Davis Concrete Services delivers with precision and care.

Conclusion:

Whether you’re restoring your driveway, upgrading your patio, or addressing long-term damage, the right concrete solution starts with a professional assessment.
At Davis Concrete Services, we combine craftsmanship, local experience, and durable materials to create concrete surfaces built to last.

If you’re in Davis, CA, or the surrounding Yolo County area, contact us today for a free estimate — and let’s find the best solution for your property.